
The Sleeping Beauties saga of 1960 is an interesting story passed down from our Cleveland elders. Lillian Fratantonio’s two little girls captivated the nation with a August 15, 1960 Life magazine article. The article was about how doctors were baffled by the case of two little Cleveland Heights girls who slipped in and out of comas.
The scan from above is from an August 12, 1960 Cleveland Press story where Mrs. Fratantonio was arrested for allegedly drugging her little girls.
Interestingly in our research we came across a March 28, 1999 Plain Dealer article where reporter Fred McGunagle recounted the ordeal of the “Sleeping Beauties”. The following week (April 4, 1999-Plain Dealer) one of the “Sleeping Beauties” daughters–Venita Fratantonio-Sapatka wrote this about her mother, “I’d like to say something on behalf of my mother, Lillian Fratantonio , and myself. So what if [my mother] made a mistake 40 years ago? She has more than made up for it since then. Why can’t you let our family members live the rest of our lives in peace? Lillian Fratantonio not only is my mother; she’s my best friend. Please forget about the “Sleeping Beauties,” because I’m wide awake and doing very well, thanks to my mother. I love my family.”
Lillian Fratantonio was always painted as some sort of historical Cleveland evil. We found it interesting how local legends can grow to something they may not actually be. After reading all we could find about the case, it seems clear that this story was about a scared and confused young woman. By most accounts Lillian went on to be an upstanding citizen who took advantage of her second chance to improve her life.